2025 Guide to Staten Island Neighborhoods
Living in Staten Island has tons of perks. It is the perfect blend of suburban and city life. Staten Island allows a slower pace of life than the city, while being close enough to visit the Big Apple often! Staten Island is home to some beautiful neighborhood. Staten Island is full of historical landmarks, beautiful parks thriving businesses and more. Here are some neighborhoods that are great to live in here in Staten Island!
Living in Staten Island offers the best of both worlds—a quieter, more suburban feel and slower pace than the city, while being close enough to visit the Big Apple often. Known for its beautiful neighborhoods, scenic parks, historic landmarks, and growing local businesses, Staten Island has something for everyone. Whether you’re looking for family-friendly communities, waterfront views, or a strong sense of local pride, these Staten Island neighborhoods are some of the best places to call home.
Pssttt… Check Out: Where Kids Eat Free Restaurants In Staten Island
Great Kills
Tucked along Staten Island’s southeastern shoreline, Great Kills is a quiet enclave that blends suburban comfort with breezy coastal charm. Originally a fishing village, this neighborhood still honors its roots with harborside restaurants, active marinas, and a laid-back pace of life that makes it especially appealing to families. Residents enjoy easy access to nature thanks to Great Kills Park, part of the Gateway National Recreation Area, offering trails, kayaking, bird-watching, and sweeping waterfront views just minutes from home.
Great Kills is a great neighborhood on Staten Island that has a rich history as a fishing village, making it an inviting suburban spot for families. With a wonderful sense of community, it beautifully combines natural charm with the conveniences of urban life, featuring parks, beaches, marinas, and the beautiful Great Kills Park, part of the Gateway National Recreation Area Great Kills has tons of thriving local businesses such as the Marina Cafe which is a harbourside restaurant and tiki bar.
The area has a vibrant commercial strip along Amboy Road and primarily offers single-family homes, along with some townhouses and apartment buildings, usually averaging around $ 720 K. Commuters can appreciate the easy access via the Staten Island Railway, various bus routes, and a quick 30-minute drive to the Staten Island Ferry. Overall, Great Kills is perfect for anyone looking for a great blend of city life and coastal peace.
The residential streets are filled with single-family homes, townhouses, and some low-rise apartment buildings, many with private driveways and yards. Homes are well-maintained, with classic styles like Cape Cods and colonials dominating the landscape. Amboy Road is a bustling main drag, lined with pizzerias, cafes, salons, and locally loved spots like Marina Cafe, a harborside restaurant with a tiki bar that draws diners year-round. Great Kills also boasts a strong sense of community, with seasonal events, youth sports leagues, and highly-rated schools reinforcing its family-friendly reputation.
For commuters, the Staten Island Railway runs directly through the neighborhood, connecting residents to the Staten Island Ferry terminal for easy access to Manhattan. Express and local buses also serve the area, and by car, the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge is about 25 minutes away, depending on traffic.
Hot Spots: Great Kills Park, Marina Café, Amboy Road shopping & dining, Crescent Beach Park
Commuter Options: Staten Island Railway (Great Kills station), express/local MTA bus routes, 30-minute drive to Staten Island Ferry
Housing Options: Single-family homes, townhouses, and some apartments
Median Home Sale Value: Around $720,000
Starting Rent for 2-Bedroom Apartment: Around $2,400
Schools: P.S. 8 Shirlee Solomon, Elias Bernstein Intermediate School 7, St. Clare School, and Staten Island Technical High School (ranked among the top in NYC)
Huguenot
This quiet, residential neighborhood on Staten Island’s South Shore appeals to families looking for space, greenery, and a strong sense of community. Known for its well-kept, contemporary homes and easy access to parks and schools, Huguenot balances suburban ease and city access, making it an ideal choice for those seeking a tranquil suburban lifestyle and urban convenience.
Here, you will find mostly single-family homes with spacious yards, newer townhouses, and semi-attached options. Commuting is manageable via the Staten Island Railway’s Huguenot station, express buses, and easy highway access; it’s about a 40-minute ride to the St. George Ferry Terminal by train or roughly 30 minutes by car. Residents also enjoy proximity to shopping centers, grocery stores, casual dining spots, and neighborhood essentials that make day-to-day living feel easy and connected.
Hot Spots: Bloomingdale Park, Huguenot Avenue shops and restaurants, Lemon Creek Park
Commuter Options: Staten Island Railway (Huguenot station), express and local buses, 30–40 minutes to the Ferry by car/train
Housing Options: Primarily single-family homes, with some townhouses and newer developments
Median Home Sale Value: $630,000
Starting Rent for 2-Bedroom Apartment: Around $2,300
Schools: P.S. 5 Huguenot School, Tottenville High School, St. Joseph. Thomas School
Huguenot is a family-friendly neighborhood known for its modern family homes and access to parks and schools, making it an ideal choice for those seeking a tranquil suburban lifestyle.
Most of the housing here consists of single-family homes, with some newer developments adding a bit of variety; the average price is around $630,000. Commuting is a breeze, thanks to walkable streets, city trains, buses, and private carriers, with travel times of about 40 minutes to the St. George Ferry Terminal by rail and roughly 30 minutes by car. Nearby areas boast plenty of shopping and dining options. Huguenot has some lovely features, like Bloomingdale Park, local eateries, and helpful services for your home needs, along with essentials like grocery stores, dry cleaners, and real estate agencies, making it a comfy and convenient spot to live.
Tottenville
Tottenville, Staten Island’s southernmost neighborhood, offers a peaceful, suburban feel with a tight-knit community. Known for its spacious homes and access to scenic waterfront parks, it blends residential comfort with historical charm. Tottenville is an ideal spot for families looking for space, quiet streets, and easy access to both nature and amenities. Once a central shipbuilding hub, Tottenville has a rich maritime history that still echoes through its landmarks, coastal views, historical sites, and charming architecture.
Residential options include spacious single-family homes, townhouses, and limited rentals. Properties here tend to be generously sized, with median home prices around $918,000. Conference House Park is a standout local gem, featuring walking trails, picnic areas, and the historic 17th-century Conference House, where peace talks were held during the Revolutionary War. Commuters benefit from the Staten Island Railway’s Tottenville station, multiple express bus routes into Manhattan, and proximity to the Outerbridge Crossing for quick access to New Jersey. Locals also enjoy a variety of family-run Italian restaurants, grocery stores, and essential services, making everyday living comfortable and convenient.
Hot Spots: Conference House Park, Biddle House, Main Street shops, and dining
Commuter Options: Staten Island Railway (Tottenville station), express/local buses, Outerbridge Crossing, ~45-minute drive to Ferry
Housing Options: Single-family homes, townhouses, limited apartment rentals
Median Home Sale Value: ~$918,000
Starting Rent for 2-Bedroom Apartment: Around $2,400
Schools: P.S. 1 Tottenville, Tottenville High School, I.S. 34, Our Lady Help of Christians School
Tottenville, Staten Island’s southernmost neighborhood, offers a quiet, suburban atmosphere with a strong sense of community. Known for its spacious homes and access to scenic waterfront parks, it blends residential comfort with historical charm.
Once a hub for shipbuilding, Tottenville has a rich maritime history that still echoes through its landmarks and coastal views. The area features a mix of single-family homes, townhouses, and a few apartment rentals, with average home prices around $918,000. Commuters benefit from the Staten Island Railway’s Tottenville station, express buses to Manhattan, being close to the Outer Bridge into New Jersey, and a roughly 45-minute drive to the Staten Island Ferry terminal. Tottenville is home to the Conference House Park, a historic Staten Island landmark built in 1680. This spot is perfect for a serene outdoor escape. Additionally, residents enjoy a variety of home-related services, Italian restaurants, dry cleaners, real estate agencies, and other essential businesses that support everyday life in this peaceful corner of the city.
Silver Lake
Nestled around its namesake reservoir, Silver Lake offers abundant green space and recreational activities, making it an attractive choice for families and nature-lovers alike. Anchored by Silver Lake Park and the historic Silver Lake Golf Course, the neighborhood offers families and nature lovers easy access to walking trails, sports fields, and tranquil water views. Just a short stroll away, the Staten Island Zoo and local cultural venues provide engaging weekend outings for all ages.
Residential streets here feature delightful single-family homes—many with original architectural details—alongside a handful of multi-family properties. With an average home price of about $850,000, the area remains one of Staten Island’s most sought-after communities. Walkability is a hallmark of Silver Lake, with quick connections to city trains, multiple bus routes, and private shuttles. Its proximity to the Staten Island Expressway and several major bus lines makes commuting to the ferry or other boroughs seamless. A thriving local scene of family-owned eateries, home services, dry cleaners, and essential shops ensures daily conveniences are always within reach.
Hot Spots: Silver Lake Park, Silver Lake Golf Course, Staten Island Zoo, Staten Island Museum
Commuter Options: Staten Island Railway (St. George station via local bus), express and local MTA buses, private shuttles, Staten Island Expressway access
Housing Options: Historic single-family homes, multi-family units
Median Home Sale Value: ~$850,000
Starting Rent for 2-Bedroom Apartment: Around $2,200
Schools: P.S. 59 George Cromwell, I.S. 27 William H. Maxwell, Susan E. Wagner High School
Adjacent to Silver Lake Park, this neighborhood offers abundant green space and recreational opportunities, making it an attractive choice for families and nature lovers. Developed around the reservoir in the early 20th century, the area has evolved into a highly desirable residential community, highlighted by the historic Silver Lake Golf Course.
Residents can enjoy being close to popular spots such as Silver Lake Park, the Staten Island Zoo, and a variety of cultural institutions. The area offers delightful single-family homes, many showcasing historic charm, along with some multi-family units, with an average home price of approximately $850,000. The neighborhood boasts walkable streets and convenient access to city trains, buses, and private transportation options. Its strategic location near the Staten Island Expressway and numerous bus lines makes commuting a breeze, especially for those heading to the ferry or other areas of the island. Local establishments encompass a mix of home services, dining options, dry cleaners, and essential services, ensuring residents have easy access to daily necessities.
Westerleigh
Known for its tree-lined streets, peaceful environment, strong community, and early 20th-century charm, Westerleigh is one of Staten Island’s most picturesque and historic neighborhoods. Developed in the late 19th century as a temperance town, Westerleigh has retained much of its historic charm, with well-preserved homes and landmarks that reflect its unique past.
The neighborhood offers a variety of single-family homes, including charming Victorian and Colonial-style houses. Its unhurried, small-town charm, walkability, and strong civic pride make it especially popular with families and long-time Staten Islanders. Residents benefit from nearby green spaces like Westerleigh Park and the College of Staten Island, which adds to the local charm. Commuting is straightforward, with several bus routes and the Staten Island Railway connecting to different areas of the borough. Additionally, reaching the Staten Island Ferry terminal takes about 30 minutes by car.
Hot Spots: Westerleigh Park, Staten Island Greenbelt, Forest Avenue dining & shops
Commuter Options: Express/local buses, Staten Island Expressway, ~30 minutes to the Ferry Terminal by car
Housing Options: Primarily single-family Colonial and Victorian homes
Median Home Sale Value: ~$780,000
Starting Rent for 2-Bedroom Apartment: Around $2,300
Schools: P.S. 30 Westerleigh, I.S. 51 Edwin Markham, Port Richmond High School
Pssttt… Check Out: Staten Island Parent Insiders’ Guide
